Editorial: Towards Collective Study in Times of Emergency
This hope no doubt seems naive, even impossible, to many. Nevertheless, some of us must rather wildly hold to it, refusing to believe that the structures that now exist will exist forever. For this, we need our poets and our dreamers, the untamed fools, the kind who know how to organise.
–Judith Butler, 13 October 20231
Since 7 October, across European public spheres, rampant censorship and self-censorship has infected institutions and been internalised by cultural producers. The refusal by western governments and media to use words pronounced by the world’s leading human rights bodies to name the decades-long occupation and apartheid and the unfolding genocide of the Palestinian people also pervades the cultural sectors. The expression of grief, anger and sadness at the killing in Palestine and Israel is even contested, while the basic humanitarian appeal for a lasting ceasefire has been opposed. Consequently, the agents of the European political and public spheres are restricting freedom of expression, rather than mediating conversations across differences.
Censorship and a heightened contestation of language reveals how interpellation is acting on, and within, public spheres, whereby the ideological positions of state and media infrastructures become internalised by citizens and articulated as their own. As this interpellation takes hold and actors are reduced to passive rather than thinking subjects, the capacity of public spheres to be shaped or moved by discourse and debate is at stake. At the same time, the global role of Europe has come under question, as it has failed to adopt any constructive or even meaningful position, either displaying its underlying acceptance of dehumanization or actively taking the side of colonial domination. International alliances and relations – including those within our network of museums, universities and arts organisations – are confronted anew with how the traces of coloniality and imperial violence, exerted from multiple directions, cross their structures.
This is where we all are – even as we are touched in different ways and to different degrees. We, the editors of L’Internationale Online, are unwilling, or unable, to write with an institutional voice, assumed or imposed. That voice, wherever it may be located, is alien. We write, however, in an attempt to find some common expression among specific, situated and generational experiences, with the aim to mobilise critical voices and to work and think collectively, beyond the interpellation of governments and the media.
The demands of the Palestinian liberation movements on cultural sectors are clear. If our institutions cannot meet them, we must acknowledge the failures and limits of our spaces, entangled as they are in broader political mechanisms. The immediate path, then, for a publishing platform like L’Internationale Online, is to utter, to speak, to work with subjectivities and situated knowledges – our own and others’. The material we plan to publish over the coming weeks and months will not be able to adequately address the extent of the daily tragedies, the contortions of debate, the historical implications of witnessing and speaking to genocide. Still, the texts, films and sounds offer a possibility to work in excess of institutional positions and to contribute to an ongoing reshaping of public spheres and critical discourses.
In addition, we see the long-term task for the cultural sphere to be to reformulate the vocabularies that have acted as the scaffolding for rhetorical frames and political positions within artistic fields, in order to overcome the weaponizing and imposed foreclosure of language. Any attempts at this will have to foster a wide appeal, building a popular front that could have the approach, the attention and the drive to effectuate such change, while knowing that such moves might lead to a fragile, tumultuous phase of in-betweenness.
Following Donna Haraway’s call to ‘think we must; we must think’ – as a struggle against Denkverbot and the shutting down of discursive spaces and practices – and after Fred Moten’s summoning of ‘collective study’, we embark on multiple lines of inquiry to navigate the shifting grounds and registers of the present conjuncture. Among these many trajectories we will turn to feminist decolonial thought and praxis to analyse the ongoing case of Israeli settler colonialism and its military and carceral regimes. We will seek to draw attention to the asymmetries in power relations and the instrumentalization of rhetorical frames, their origins and their consequences in the European context. And in a forthcoming article Ovidiu Tichindeleanu outlines the repression within European public spheres and the entanglement of this with imperial histories. As acts of solidarity, we will platform the work of artists, poets, musicians and film-makers working past the limits of language to think through the present and its myriad implications and inflections. The publishing here will be necessarily partial and incomplete. It is not approached as a declaration, or an answer. Rather, to recall Audre Lorde, we approach it as an exercise in finding the words we do not have.
Related activities
-
Institute of Radical ImaginationMSU Zagreb
Red, Green, Black and White
A performative inquiry by Institute of Radical Imagination and MSU Zagreb
-
–Institute of Radical Imagination
Gathering into the Maelstrom
‘Gathering into the Maelstrom’ in Venice at Sale Docks is a four-day programme curated by Institute of Radical Imagination (IRI) and Sale Docks.
-
–MACBA
Song for Many Movements: Scenes of Collective Creation
An ephemeral experiment in which the ground floor of MACBA becomes a stage for encounters, conversations and shared listening.
-
Museo Reina Sofia
Palestine Is Everywhere
‘Palestine Is Everywhere’ is an encounter and screening at Museo Reina Sofía organised together with Cinema as Assembly as part of Museum of the Commons. The conference starts at 18:30 pm (CET) and will also be streamed on the online platform linked below.
-
–Van Abbemuseum
The Soils Project
‘The Soils Project’ is part of an eponymous, long-term research initiative involving TarraWarra Museum of Art (Wurundjeri Country, Australia), the Van Abbemuseum (Eindhoven, Netherlands) and Struggles for Sovereignty, a collective based in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. It works through specific and situated practices that consider soil, as both metaphor and matter.
Seeking and facilitating opportunities to listen to diverse voices and perspectives around notions of caring for land, soil and sovereign territories, the project has been in development since 2018. An international collaboration between three organisations, and several artists, curators, writers and activists, it has manifested in various iterations over several years. The group exhibition ‘Soils’ at the Van Abbemuseum is part of Museum of the Commons. -
–VCRC
Kyiv Biennial 2023
L’Internationale Confederation is a proud partner of this year’s edition of Kyiv Biennial.
-
–MACBA
Where are the Oases?
PEI OBERT seminar
with Kader Attia, Elvira Dyangani Ose, Max Jorge Hinderer Cruz, Emily Jacir, Achille Mbembe, Sarah Nuttall and Françoise VergèsAn oasis is the potential for life in an adverse environment.
-
MACBA
Anti-imperialism in the 20th century and anti-imperialism today: similarities and differences
PEI OBERT seminar
Lecture by Ramón GrosfoguelIn 1956, countries that were fighting colonialism by freeing themselves from both capitalism and communism dreamed of a third path, one that did not align with or bend to the politics dictated by Washington or Moscow. They held their first conference in Bandung, Indonesia.
-
Institute of Radical ImaginationMuseo Reina Sofia
Cinema as Assembly
Cinema as Assembly investigates cinema as a space of social gathering and political engagement that prefigures and enacts forms of living beyond colonial capitalism.
-
21 Jun 2023 –6 Jul Van AbbemuseumMaria Lugones Decolonial Summer School
Recalling Earth: Decoloniality and Demodernity
Course Directors: Prof. Walter Mignolo & Dr. Rolando VázquezRecalling Earth and learning worlds and worlds-making will be the topic of chapter 14th of the María Lugones Summer School that will take place at the Van Abbemuseum in Eindhoven.
-
23 Apr 2023 –30 Sep 2024 MSNArchive of the Conceptual Art of Odesa in the 1980s
The research project turns to the beginning of 1980s, when conceptual art circle emerged in Odesa, Ukraine. Artists worked independently and in collaborations creating the first examples of performances, paradoxical objects and drawings.
-
24 Aug 2024 –30 Aug Moderna galerijaZRC SAZUSummer School: Our Many Easts
Our Many Easts summer school is organised by Moderna galerija in Ljubljana in partnership with ZRC SAZU (the Research Centre of the Slovenian Academy of Sciences and Arts) as part of the L’Internationale project Museum of the Commons.
-
15 Feb 2024 –15 Mar Moderna galerijaZRC SAZUOpen Call – Summer School: Our Many Easts
Our Many Easts summer school takes place in Ljubljana 24–30 August and the application deadline is 15 March. Courses will be held in English and cover topics such as the legacy of the Eastern European avant-gardes, archives as tools of emancipation, the new “non-aligned” networks, art in times of conflict and war, ecology and the environment.
-
23 Jan 2025 HDK-ValandBook Launch: Collective Study in Times of Emergency, Gothenburg
with Nick Aikens (L'Internationale Online / HDK-Valand) and Mills Dray (HDK-Valand), Glashuset, 17h00
-
28 Jan 2025 Moderna galerijaBook Launch: Collective Study in Times of Emergency, Ljubljana
with Nick Aikens (L'Internationale Online / HDK-Valand)), Bojana Piškur, (MG+MSUM)) and Martin Pogačar (ZRC SAZU)
-
27 Nov 2024 –17 Nov WIELSBook Launch: Collective Study in Times of Emergency, Brussels
with Nick Aikens (L'Internationale Online / HDK-Valand), Subversive Film and Alex Reynolds, 19h00, Wiles Auditorium
Related contributions and publications
-
Diary of a Crossing
Baqiya and Yu’ad27 Mar 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Until Liberation II: Learning Palestine
Learning Palestine Group12 Jan 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Until Liberation I: Learning Palestine
Learning Palestine Group8 Dec 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Live set: A Love Letter to the Global Intifada
Precolumbian13 Jun 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencySonic CommonsPast in the PresentMACBAEN es -
The Genocide War on Gaza: Palestinian Culture and the Existential Struggle
Rana Anani10 Sep 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Right now, today, we must say that Palestine is the centre of the world
Françoise Vergès21 Dec 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Everything will stay the same if we don’t speak up
L’Internationale Confederation17 Apr 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyStatements and editorialsPast in the PresentSituated OrganizationsEN ca -
…and the Earth along. Tales about the making, remaking and unmaking of the world.
Martin Pogačar14 Nov 2023 ... and the Earth alongClimatePast in the Present -
Statement on the attack on Kakhovka Water Dam
L’Internationale Confederation11 Jun 2023 Statements and editorials -
The Kitchen, an Introduction to Subversive Film with Nick Aikens, Reem Shilleh and Mohanad Yaqubi
Nick Aikens, Subversive Film13 Jul 2023 lumbungPast in the PresentVan Abbemuseum -
The Repressive Tendency within the European Public Sphere
Ovidiu Ţichindeleanu6 Dec 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Troubles with the East(s)
Bojana Piškur22 Jan 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Body Counts, Balancing Acts and the Performativity of Statements
Mick Wilson20 Dec 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
In solidarity with all the people affected by the earthquake in Turkiye and Syria
L’Internationale Confederation13 Feb 2023 Statements and editorials -
Public letter on WHW termination as directors of Kunsthalle Wien
L’Internationale Confederation10 Jan 2023 Statements and editorials -
Statement in support of documenta fifteen
L’Internationale Confederation27 Jul 2022 Statements and editorialslumbung -
Never Again War!
L’Internationale Confederation28 Feb 2022 Statements and editorialsEN es pl sl sv ca nl uk -
Statement on the dismissal of Alistair Hudson
L’Internationale Confederation27 Feb 2022 Statements and editorials -
L’Internationale Public Statement on the recent events at MACBA
L’Internationale Confederation21 Jul 2021 Statements and editorialsMACBA -
L’Internationale statement: Towards a healthy society
5 May 2020 Statements and editorials -
Standing up for the rights of all artists to free and independent expression
L’Internationale Confederation11 Dec 2018 Statements and editorials -
Tearing Down Bridges – Turkey's Withdrawal from Creative Europe
L’Internationale Confederation29 Sep 2016 Statements and editorials -
Of Cats and Canary Birds: Statement in Support of Lunds Konsthall
L’Internationale Confederation17 Dec 2015 Statements and editorials -
How Much Austerity Can Europe Endure?
L’Internationale Confederation4 Jul 2015 Statements and editorials -
L'Internationale supports Walid Raad, Andrew Ross and Ashok Sukumaran after the recent ban on their entry to the UAE
L’Internationale Confederation21 May 2015 Statements and editorials -
L'Internationale statement in support of the decision to open "La Bestia y el soberano" (The Beast and the Sovereign)
L’Internationale Confederation21 Mar 2015 Statements and editorialsMACBA -
Artists for Kobanê: An online auction to benefit refugees from Kobanê
L’Internationale Online Editorial Board3 Dec 2014 Statements and editorials -
L'Internationale statement in support of MNCARS
L’Internationale Confederation4 Nov 2014 Statements and editorialsMuseo Reina SofiaEN es sl nl tr -
New online platform for research, resources and discussion
L’Internationale Confederation17 Sep 2014 Statements and editorials -
The Veil of Peace
Ovidiu Ţichindeleanu31 Oct 2023 Past in the Presenttranzit.ro -
Editorial: Towards Collective Study in Times of Emergency
L’Internationale Online Editorial Board29 Nov 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyStatements and editorialsPast in the PresentEN es sl tr ar -
Song for Many Movements. Opening Performance Live on Radio Alhara
Jokkoo with/con Miramizu, Rasheed Jalloul & Sabine Salamé23 Feb 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencySonic CommonsPast in the PresentMACBAEN es -
We Have Been Here Forever. Palestinian Poets Write Back
Rana Issa4 Mar 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Indra's Web
Vandana Singh1 Mar 2024 ... and the Earth alongPast in the PresentClimateZRC SAZU -
The Silence Has Been Unfolding For Too Long
The Free Palestine Initiative Croatia11 Apr 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the PresentSituated OrganizationsInstitute of Radical ImaginationMSU Zagreb -
One Day, Freedom Will Be
Françoise Vergès, Maddalena Fragnito19 Apr 2024 Art for Radical Ecologies ManifestoTowards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyInstitute of Radical ImaginationClimate -
War, Peace and Image Politics: Part 1, Who Has a Right to These Images?
Jelena Vesić14 May 2024 Past in the PresentZRC SAZU -
Cultivating Abundance
Åsa Sonjasdotter28 Jun 2024 The Climate ForumClimatePast in the PresentHDK-Valand -
Reading list - Summer School: Our Many Easts
Summer School - Our Many Easts6 Sep 2024 Past in the PresentModerna galerija -
Eating clay is not an eating disorder
Zayaan Khan17 Sep 2024 The Climate ForumRecette. Reset. Recipes in and Beyond the InstitutionClimatePast in the Present -
Dispatch: ‘I don't believe in revolution, but sometimes I get in the spirit.’
Megan Hoetger20 Sep 2024 Past in the Present -
Dispatch: Notes on (de)growth from the fragments of Yugoslavia's former alliances
Ava Zevop24 Sep 2024 Past in the Present -
Forget ‘never again’, it’s always already war
Martin Pogačar3 Oct 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the PresentZRC SAZU -
Broadcast: Towards Collective Study in Times of Emergency (for 24 hrs/Palestine)
L’Internationale Online Editorial Board, Rana Issa, L’Internationale Confederation, Vijay Prashad16 Oct 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencySonic Commons -
Beyond Distorted Realities: Palestine, Magical Realism and Climate Fiction
Sanabel Abdel Rahman14 Nov 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the PresentClimate -
Collective Study in Times of Emergency. A Roundtable
Nick Aikens, Sara Buraya Boned, Charles Esche, Martin Pogačar, Ovidiu Ţichindeleanu, Ezgi Yurteri15 Nov 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the PresentSituated Organizations -
Present Present Present. On grounding the Mediateca and Sonotera spaces in Malafo, Guinea-Bissau
Filipa César27 Nov 2024 Past in the Present -
Collective Study in Times of Emergency
2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
S is for Silence
Maddalena Fragnito13 Jan 2025 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencySituated OrganizationsEN it -
Milad: The Birth of a Dream and Its Continuation
Sanaa Salameh20 Jan 2025 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the PresentEN ar -
The Library and the Massacre: A Novelist's Testimony on the Destruction of Libraries in the Gaza Strip
Yousri al-Ghoul20 Jan 2025 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the PresentEN ar