The Silence Has Been Unfolding For Too Long
The following statement was publicly read by Free Palestine Initiative Croatia on 21 January 2024. The reading took place at the end of ‘Red Green, Black and White’ – the performative inquiry by Institute of Radical Imagination hanging the Guernica Falasteene banner claiming “Stand up for Palestine. Stop Censorship” on MSU Zagreb’s facade in the presence of the press and participants.
‘The silence has been unfolding for too long. The longer it unfolds, the more compelling it becomes. It puts on different coats. Each of them being oddly familiar. We put on our coat of silence for we can’t digest what the eye captures. We are silent for we avoid deeper understanding. It would impose a new demand on us. We keep being silent for we look away. Straight looking would mean witnessing, and witnessing calls for accountability. We breathe silence when we don't call out the others for that would mean calling out ourselves. Remaining unaccountable. We are silent for many are. For being ashamed, for perhaps never using our voice for the (O)thers.
We endure the silence for it provides the safety of belonging. To the silent majority. Fenced off the world. The silence is kind. And we don’t want to be unkind to kindness. The silence feels good enough. The loyalty to silence doesn’t stand out inscribed in our foreheads. The silence thinks no evil. The silence has no thoughts. The silence emerges with a good intention paving a path to someone else’s hell. The Free Palestine Initiative understands the silences we are coated into. We tell all the ones who are troubled with showing up in the streets and joining the protests, performances and other public events, that you are not alone and that you don’t have to endure the burden of silence solely by yourself.
Not even the burden of not using your own voice!
The system of negation of the individual and collective human experience counts on your isolation as it has long counted on the isolation of Palestinians, whose lives began and ended in a clear awareness that they were born alone, and that the very act of their birth was invisible. Their happiness is invisible, as is their misery. They are invisible and even unknown as human beings, as part of brotherhood and sisterhood in the universe.
Despite all the sophisticated possibilities of witnessing the Palestinian experience of occupation, in its most radical version – erasing not only people from the face of the Earth but also the very face of the Earth – it remains invisible. Parents contemplating strategies for sleeping under bombs are invisible. Names written in Arabic script on the white surface of bags containing mortal remains are invisible.
Dear compatriots, all of you who have not yet said JUSTICE FREEDOM PEACE EQUALITY FOR ALL, we want to say that the choice of not making a choice is still a choice. The decision we have not made is also a decision. Your silence is not neutrality or objectivity but an alignment with the long historical tradition of the so-called bystanders, those who have witnessed the horrors inflicted on others and remained silent.
So we say it again – you are not alone, you don’t have to be alone, and the only thing needed is the decision to extend a hand. We intend to be within reach. We are going nowhere, and we judge no one for what cannot be judged, breaking the silence in this moment – on the 106th day of the relentless collective destruction of the people of Gaza – with a song about the ones who were taken away from us.’
Zagreb, 21 January 2024
The views and opinions published here mirror the principles of academic freedom and do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of the L'Internationale confederation and its members.
Related activities
-
–Van Abbemuseum
The Soils Project
‘The Soils Project’ is part of an eponymous, long-term research initiative involving TarraWarra Museum of Art (Wurundjeri Country, Australia), the Van Abbemuseum (Eindhoven, Netherlands) and Struggles for Sovereignty, a collective based in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. It works through specific and situated practices that consider soil, as both metaphor and matter.
Seeking and facilitating opportunities to listen to diverse voices and perspectives around notions of caring for land, soil and sovereign territories, the project has been in development since 2018. An international collaboration between three organisations, and several artists, curators, writers and activists, it has manifested in various iterations over several years. The group exhibition ‘Soils’ at the Van Abbemuseum is part of Museum of the Commons. -
–VCRC
Kyiv Biennial 2023
L’Internationale Confederation is a proud partner of this year’s edition of Kyiv Biennial.
-
–MACBA
The Open Kitchen. The fermented seed, colonialism and extractivism
The MACBA Kitchen is a working group situated against the backdrop of ecosocial crisis. Participants in the group aim to highlight the importance of intuitively imagining an ecofeminist kitchen, and take a particular interest in the wisdom of individuals, projects and experiences that work with dislocated knowledge in relation to food sovereignty.
-
MACBA
The Kitchen: Workshop by Marina Monsonís
The Kitchen is a meeting place open to the participation of all, especially people and organizations that want to share their knowledge and experiences around the kitchen.
-
8 Sep 2023 –31 Dec MSNMulticultural Youth Center
The Museum of Modern Art in Warsaw, together with the confederation of museums L'Internationale, is establishing a Multicultural Youth Center. This is a unique space for 16-24 year olds to explore and develop their creativity, make new friends and hang out in a friendly and supportive environment.
-
12 Apr 2023 –14 Apr MACBAWhere are the Oases?
PEI OBERT seminar
with Kader Attia, Elvira Dyangani Ose, Max Jorge Hinderer Cruz, Emily Jacir, Achille Mbembe, Sarah Nuttall and Françoise VergèsAn oasis is the potential for life in an adverse environment.
-
2023 – 2024 MACBAMobile Garden. A Place to Meet
An open space, a social space. How could the Museum be more open to the needs of the neighbourhood?
-
14 Dec 2023 MACBAAnti-imperialism in the 20th century and anti-imperialism today: similarities and differences
PEI OBERT seminar
Lecture by Ramón GrosfoguelIn 1956, countries that were fighting colonialism by freeing themselves from both capitalism and communism dreamed of a third path, one that did not align with or bend to the politics dictated by Washington or Moscow. They held their first conference in Bandung, Indonesia.
-
2023 – 2024 Museo Reina SofiaSchool of Commoning Practices
This exchange programme gathers different schools organized by volunteers and migrant communities in Athens (Open School for Migrants) and Madrid (School of Rights, Escuela de Español and Situated mediation School) in order to share their knowledge, exchange strategies and reflect on the experience of working together with migrant communities.
-
2023 – 2026 Institute of Radical ImaginationMuseo Reina SofiaCinema as Assembly
Cinema as Assembly investigates cinema as a space of social gathering and political engagement that prefigures and enacts forms of living beyond colonial capitalism.
-
1 Sep 2023 –30 Jun 2024 Museo Reina SofiaTeam of Teams
This project researches citizen participation as a fundamental pillar in the creation of community.
-
1 Apr 2024 –21 Dec 2025 Museo Reina SofiaSustainable Art Production
The Studies Center of Museo Reina Sofía will publish an open call for 4 residencies of artistic practice for projects that address the emergencies and challenges derived from the climate crisis such as food sovereignty, architecture and sustainability, communal practices, diasporas and exiles or ecological and political sustainability, among others.
-
21 Jun 2023 –6 Jul Van AbbemuseumMaria Lugones Decolonial Summer School
Recalling Earth: Decoloniality and Demodernity
Course Directors: Prof. Walter Mignolo & Dr. Rolando VázquezRecalling Earth and learning worlds and worlds-making will be the topic of chapter 14th of the María Lugones Summer School that will take place at the Van Abbemuseum in Eindhoven.
-
9 Dec 2023 M HKASUPERHOST | Club Antena. Intimate listening and dancing experience
with Nele Möller, Farida Amadou, Le Réalism, Céline Gillain, Roberta Miss, Elena Colombi
CLUB ANTENA is an intimate listening and dancing session with a lecture, concert, performance, catering and DJ sets, exploring what it means to listen with our bodies.
-
24 Jan 2024 Institute of Radical ImaginationMSU ZagrebRed, Green, Black and White
A performative inquiry by Institute of Radical Imagination and MSU Zagreb
-
2023 – 2027 HKWTongue and Throat Memories
On hospitality and conviviality through food
Knowledges and convenings
Cooking Sessions -
23 Apr 2023 –30 Sep 2024 MSNArchive of the Conceptual Art of Odesa in the 1980s
The research project turns to the beginning of 1980s, when conceptual art circle emerged in Odesa, Ukraine. Artists worked independently and in collaborations creating the first examples of performances, paradoxical objects and drawings.
-
24 Aug 2024 –30 Aug Moderna galerijaZRC SAZUSummer School: Our Many Easts
Our Many Easts summer school is organised by Moderna galerija in Ljubljana in partnership with ZRC SAZU (the Research Centre of the Slovenian Academy of Sciences and Arts) as part of the L’Internationale project Museum of the Commons.
-
15 Feb 2024 –15 Mar Moderna galerijaZRC SAZUOpen Call – Summer School: Our Many Easts
Our Many Easts summer school takes place in Ljubljana 24–30 August and the application deadline is 15 March. Courses will be held in English and cover topics such as the legacy of the Eastern European avant-gardes, archives as tools of emancipation, the new “non-aligned” networks, art in times of conflict and war, ecology and the environment.
-
10 Feb 2024 –1 Apr MACBASong for Many Movements: Scenes of Collective Creation
An ephemeral experiment in which the ground floor of MACBA becomes a stage for encounters, conversations and shared listening.
-
4 Feb 2024 –10 Mar MSU ZagrebVan AbbemuseumModerna galerijaZRC SAZUOpen Call – School of Common Knowledge
MSU (Zagreb), Van Abbemuseum (Eindhoven), MG+MSUM (Ljubljana), ZRC SAZU (Ljubljana) and L'Internationale invite applications for the new School of Common Knowledge (SCK) to be held in Zagreb and Ljubljana 24–29 May 2024. The School of Common Knowledge draws on the network, knowledge and experience of the L’Internationale museum confederation. Its ambition is to be both nomadic and situated, looking at specific cultural and geopolitical situations while exploring their relations and interdependencies with the rest of the world. The SCK is built on the basis laid by the Glossary of Common Knowledge project initiated by Zdenka Badovinac and Moderna galerija (Ljubljana) and continues its co-learning methodology.
-
17 Apr 2024 –20 Apr Institute of Radical ImaginationGathering into the Maelstrom
‘Gathering into the Maelstrom’ in Venice at Sale Docks is a four-day programme curated by Institute of Radical Imagination (IRI) and Sale Docks.
-
24 May 2024 –30 May MSU ZagrebVan AbbemuseumModerna galerijaZRC SAZUSchool of Common Knowledge
School of Common Knowledge draws on the network, knowledge and experience of the L’Internationale museum confederation. Built on the basis laid by the Glossary of Common Knowledge, a project initiated by Zdenka Badovinac and Moderna Galerija in Ljubljana, it continues its co-learning methodology. Its ambition is to be both nomadic and situated, looking at specific cultural and geopolitical situations while exploring their relations and interdependencies with the rest of the world.
-
16 May 2024 –21 Jul Institute of Radical ImaginationGathering into the Maelstrom (exhibition)
‘Gathering into the Maelstrom’ is curated by Institute of Radical Imagination and Sale Docks within the framework of Museum of the Commons.
Related contributions and publications
-
…and the Earth along. Tales about the making, remaking and unmaking of the world.
Martin Pogačar14 Nov 2023 ... and the Earth alongClimatePast in the Present -
Art for Radical Ecologies Manifesto
Institute of Radical Imagination15 Nov 2023 Art for Radical Ecologies ManifestoClimateInstitute of Radical Imagination -
The Kitchen, an Introduction to Subversive Film with Nick Aikens, Reem Shilleh and Mohanad Yaqubi
Nick Aikens, Subversive Film13 Jul 2023 lumbungPast in the PresentVan Abbemuseum -
The Repressive Tendency within the European Public Sphere
Ovidiu Ţichindeleanu6 Dec 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Troubles with the East(s)
Bojana Piškur22 Jan 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Right now, today, we must say that Palestine is the centre of the world
Françoise Vergès21 Dec 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Body Counts, Balancing Acts and the Performativity of Statements
Mick Wilson20 Dec 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Until Liberation I: Learning Palestine
Learning Palestine Group8 Dec 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Until Liberation II: Learning Palestine
Learning Palestine Group12 Jan 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Lumbung practices to resist and collaborate through art
Constanza Yévenes Biénzobas30 Aug 2023 lumbungSituated OrganizationsMuseo Reina SofiaEN es -
Some Guiding Terms for Lumbung Press: Defining “publishing”
Erick Beltrán27 Apr 2023 lumbungSituated OrganizationsMACBAEN es -
The Veil of Peace
Ovidiu Ţichindeleanu31 Oct 2023 Past in the Presenttranzit.ro -
Editorial: Towards Collective Study in Times of Emergency
L’Internationale Online Editorial Board29 Nov 2023 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyStatements and editorialsPast in the PresentEN es sl tr ar -
Song for Many Movements. Opening Performance Live on Radio Alhara
Jokkoo with/con Miramizu, Rasheed Jalloul & Sabine Salamé23 Feb 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencySonic CommonsPast in the PresentMACBAEN es -
We Have Been Here Forever. Palestinian Poets Write Back
Rana Issa4 Mar 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Discomfort at Dinner: The role of food work in challenging empire
Mary Fawzy29 Feb 2024 Recette. Reset. Recipes in and Beyond the InstitutionSituated Organizations -
Indra's Web
Vandana Singh1 Mar 2024 ... and the Earth alongPast in the PresentClimateZRC SAZU -
Mix tape: Let's Funk Up All Genders!
Materia Hache / Others to the Front19 Mar 2024 Sonic CommonsSituated OrganizationsMuseo Reina SofiaEN es -
Diary of a Crossing
Baqiya and Yu’ad27 Mar 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Towards Collective Learning, or, Decompartmentalizing Education
María Berríos, Fran MM Cabeza de Vaca, Yolande Zola Zoli van der Heide, Nick Aikens4 Apr 2024 Situated Organizations -
The Silence Has Been Unfolding For Too Long
The Free Palestine Initiative Croatia11 Apr 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the PresentSituated OrganizationsInstitute of Radical ImaginationMSU Zagreb -
One Day, Freedom Will Be
Françoise Vergès19 Apr 2024 Art for Radical Ecologies ManifestoTowards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyInstitute of Radical ImaginationClimate -
Everything will stay the same if we don’t speak up
L’Internationale Confederation17 Apr 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyStatements and editorialsPast in the PresentSituated OrganizationsEN ca -
Art and Materialisms: At the intersection of New Materialisms and Operaismo
Emanuele Braga1 May 2024 Art for Radical Ecologies ManifestoInstitute of Radical ImaginationClimate -
Reading list: School of Common Knowledge 2024
School of Common Knowledge21 May 2024 School of Common KnowledgeSituated OrganizationsMSU ZagrebModerna galerijaZRC SAZU -
War, Peace and Image Politics: Part 1, Who Has a Right to These Images?
Jelena Vesić14 May 2024 Past in the PresentZRC SAZU -
Dispatch: Notes on Separation and Conviviality
Raluca Popa28 May 2024 Situated Organizationstranzit.ro -
To Build an Ecological Art Institution: The Experimental Station for Research on Art and Life
Ovidiu Ţichindeleanu, Raluca Voinea31 May 2024 Art for Radical Ecologies ManifestoClimateSituated Organizationstranzit.ro -
Art, Radical Ecologies and Class Composition: On the possible alliance between historical and new materialisms
Marco Baravalle12 Jun 2024 Art for Radical Ecologies ManifestoInstitute of Radical ImaginationClimate -
Live set: A Love Letter to the Global Intifada
Precolombian13 Jun 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencySonic CommonsPast in the PresentMACBAEN es -
‘Territorios en resistencia’, Artistic Perspectives from Latin America
Rosa Jijón & Francesco Martone (A4C), Sofía Acosta Varea, Boloh Miranda Izquierdo, Anamaría Garzón26 Jun 2024 Art for Radical Ecologies ManifestoClimateInstitute of Radical Imagination -
Dispatch: In between the lessons. Staying together in uncertain times, laughing in the face of trouble, and disobeying; the future belongs to us
Antonela Solenički19 Jun 2024 School of Common KnowledgeSituated OrganizationsMSU ZagrebModerna galerijaZRC SAZU -
Dispatch: The Commonsverse and Situated Organisations – or why the era of big institutions will come to an end
Denise Pollini19 Jun 2024 School of Common KnowledgeSituated OrganizationsMSU ZagrebModerna galerijaZRC SAZU -
Dispatch: A Buriti Tree
Lucas Pretti10 Jul 2024 School of Common KnowledgeMSU ZagrebModerna galerijaZRC SAZUSituated Organizations -
Unhinging the Dual Machine: The Politics of Radical Kinship for a Different Art Ecology
Federica Timeto1 Jul 2024 Art for Radical Ecologies ManifestoInstitute of Radical ImaginationClimate -
Cultivating Abundance
Åsa Sonjasdotter28 Jun 2024 The Climate ForumClimatePast in the PresentHDK-Valand -
Naming a Collective Cause in a Foreign Land
Dagmary Olívar Graterol, Paola de la Vega Velastegui5 Jul 2024 Situated OrganizationsMuseo Reina SofiaEN es -
Dispatch: To whom it may concern – the voice of the censor and re-calibrating words as an act of survival
Anonymous27 Jun 2024 School of Common KnowledgeSituated OrganizationsMSU ZagrebModerna galerijaZRC SAZU -
Rethinking Comradeship from a Feminist Position
Leonida Kovač18 Jul 2024 School of Common KnowledgeSituated OrganizationsMSU ZagrebModerna galerijaZRC SAZU -
Reading list - Summer School: Our Many Easts
Summer School - Our Many Easts6 Sep 2024 Past in the PresentModerna galerija -
The Genocide War on Gaza: Palestinian Culture and the Existential Struggle
Rana Anani10 Sep 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the Present -
Eating clay is not an eating disorder
Zayaan Khan17 Sep 2024 The Climate ForumRecette. Reset. Recipes in and Beyond the InstitutionClimatePast in the Present -
Dispatch: ‘I don't believe in revolution, but sometimes I get in the spirit.’
Megan Hoetger20 Sep 2024 Past in the Present -
Dispatch: Notes on (de)growth from the fragments of Yugoslavia's former alliances
Ava Zevop24 Sep 2024 Past in the Present -
Forget ‘never again’, it’s always already war
Martin Pogačar3 Oct 2024 Towards Collective Study in Times of EmergencyPast in the PresentZRC SAZU